Access auditors are always on the lookout for examples of good and poor visual contrast in, and around buildings and sites. They may talk of colour contrast, visual contrast, and sometimes even tonal contrast. LRV or Light Reflectance Values might be mentioned, and the 30 point difference between adjacent surfaces, to aid vision–impaired people and others.
But do we really understand the limitations of our advice in this field? I refer to ‘The Colour Light and Contrast Manual’ by Keith Bright and Geoff Cook. This is a good starting point to understand the relationships between measuring light and contrast, and colour.
Greyscale
Some auditors provide a greyscale image of a scene to better understand the visual effect of visual contrast. That tends to be quite useful, but also has its limitations. The camera or Smartphone you take the picture with uses internal filters and electronics to take the pictures. The sensitivity or ISO rating used can make a difference to the final picture. That is not to say you should stop using greyscale examples in your audit.
LRV – Confusing or what?
Clients reading access audits may never have heard of LRV’s before. Having a simple definition before the start of the audit, or alternatively, having it in the Appendix, can help a lot. But you still must use LRV’s in the correct context, in an audit or report.
Some auditors might say ‘The floor and wall LRV was inadequate’, or even ‘More LRV is required at the partition’. That can be quite confusing for the reader, who is probably not familiar with BS 8300 or Part M Approved Document Volume 2. Communication is the key here.
What you are trying to say is that the difference between certain components or finishes does not meet the minimum recommended difference in tonal, or visual contrast to make them apparent from a distance. The minimum recommended difference being 30 point LRV measured on a scale from 0-100, where 0 is nearly pure black, and that pure white at the other end of the scale is 100. (And that pure black and pure white doesn’t even exist in practice!).
That scale is based on at least 100 lux illumination level, at the point the contrast is viewed, so if it’s lower lighting than 100 lux, that then could affect the advice you give the client.
But are you also going to tell the client that evidence may indicate that LRV differences of 20 might also be O.K. for some vision-impaired people to perceive a difference? Or that that lower standard is linked directly to the level of illumination in the space or area, with a minimum of 200 lux mentioned in BS8300? Now it’s getting a bit too technical.
The client just wants to know ‘Do I have to change the decoration or not, between the door and the architrave?’ The guidance in BS8300 on LRV’s came originally from BS 8494:2008. (Now updated to BS8494:2008+A1: 2010). But that is not particularly helpful to our client. Better to keep it simple.
Dr G. Cook’s research in 2005 identified that visual contrast between a door and door handle could be reduced to as little as 15 point LRV difference, where the illuminance was 200 lux. This is acknowledged in BS8300. However, it is wise to read the guidance in Annex B of BS8300, which discourages less than 20 point LRV difference for most situations, even in bright lighting.
The high street and visual perception
Carrying out a street access audit in West London some years ago, I was looking at street furniture and colour and visual contrast for a Local authority. A lot of parking signage was obsolete, or duplicated in places, and could be removed.



I had great difficulty in certain light conditions to find my way safely up and down the high street. This was due to the changing angle of the sun, formation of deep shadows, and reflections on the ground from adjacent windows, and advertising boards. This was a high street I was very familiar with, having done many measurements over several weeks. But at times, it was as though I could have been in a completely different high street, and unfamiliar with it.
Morphing of shapes
The wide range of street furniture and obstructions ranged from litter bins to bollards; from bench seats positioned at different angles, to advertising display boards; lamp-posts to parking payment machines. Telecoms metal cabinets of different shapes and sizes. The shapes changed their appearance at different times of the day in winter, due to deep shadows, changing light and colour temperature of the wavebands of light, further complicated with numerous reflections. It was like the shapes were morphing from one shape to another.
As someone who did not consider myself vision-impaired, (except by wearing glasses), at times I felt quite frightened and intimidated by that high street. What a vision-impaired person would make of it would be interesting, with limited vision and their perception of objects. Light does play certain tricks on our interpretation of objects, and our spacial-awareness.
We cannot change natural daylight and the sun, but we can take into account their effects within our environment. A combination of natural and artificial light is common, but even these combined effects can vary. More research is needed in this field.
References:
- The Colour Light and Contrast Manual –Professor Keith Bright and Dr G. Cook-Wiley-Blackwell.
- BS8300-2:2018 Annex B (Informative) Using light reflectance values (LRV’s) to assess visual contrast
- BS8494:2008+A1: 2010
Link to Colour to Greyscale image: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0029740






