Most people reading this will be aware of the Social Model approach to disability. But given current momentum around equality and inclusion, and the greater (but not yet great enough) levels of discussion of subjects such as racism, does limiting thinking to the Social Model of disability and focusing primarily on one Protected Characteristic group at a time potentially hold us back in the movement towards greater levels of inclusion?
Is it time for access and inclusion professional’s approach (and terminology) to evolve beyond that of the Social Model of disability?
The Social Model of disability is based on the premise that people themselves are not disabled. There is great variation in our population, some of that variation is physical, sensory or cognitive. The Social Model describes these variations as ‘impairments’.
The (Cambridge) dictionary definition of ‘impairment’ is:
“the act of spoiling something or making it weaker so that it is less effective”
Within which there are obvious negative connotations.

The concern being that people may or may not be aware of these potential negative connotations (for themselves or others) when they use the term.
There is no denying that the Social Model has been fundamental in achieving the shift in thinking from the traditional medical based approach of:
‘disabled people have something wrong with them, it is therefore their fault they face barriers in life, to participation, employment, and to the built environment, which for many years was used to let most people ‘off the hook’ in terms of questioning their own actions and thought processes in relation to this group,’
to the more mainstreamed inclusive approach of:
‘everyone is different (therefore the concept of ‘difference’ could be questioned- however that is a whole other article!), and the built environment, services and management practices should be designed to incorporate and accommodate the difference represented in our diverse population.’
Which has made a massive difference to millions of people’s lives. Many members are now working on areas now which were not necessarily considered at all 15 years ago;
- Changing Places toilets – which takes consideration beyond the traditional ‘95th percentile’ approach of British Standards and Part M (i.e. the guidance in these documents consciously provided solutions for a proportion of disabled people);
- designing for people with neurodiverse conditions was not generally considered – yet we are now in the position of the first national standard being developed on the subject;
- providing a range of toilet facilities not just for disabled people, but for people with a range of cultural requirements, for people of all genders, gender identities and expressions.

The approach of separating out impairment and disability could be described as a master stroke resulting in people questioning their own thinking, how they viewed disabled people and their own approach- which would now be termed as their ‘unconscious biases’. All of which is essential to mainstreaming the subject of access and inclusion, as well as disabled people being seen as part of mainstream society.
However, there are still individuals for whom the Social Model has not been successful in achieving that shift in understanding, so would a slightly different approach or framing of the subject be more effective in enhancing their level of understanding of the subject?
Coupling this with potential negative connotations the term ‘impairment’ may have (for some), do we need to be more inclusive with our application of the Social Model, building on the Social Models success?
Do we need to be making the links to the barriers faced more widely by people due to their coming under one or more of the other Protected Characteristics?
Not doing so, and not taking a more holistic approach to inclusion, could cause ‘Protected Characteristic clash’ where the requirements of one Protected Characteristic group when considered in isolation could cause difficulties for another.
It could be argued that the Paulley V First Bus PLC case was an example of just this.
In terms of access for disabled people we already do this – taking into account the range of requirements within national guidance, to resolve or make a call on potential conflicts (for example the extent of provision of tactile paving – which can be problematic for wheelchair users).

However, to achieve this – do we need to move away from the term ‘impairment’, which – due to the success of the Social Model approach now has firm links with disability?
It should probably also be questioned whether we at the right stage to make the next shift in approach. Many would argue we are not as:
- a basic level of access and inclusion for disabled people is often still not achieved- broadening out the parameters could potentially cause a dilution and result in even less inclusive solutions for disabled people
- government do not consistently apply the Social Model throughout their work, and often use medicalised terms in publications. But do we wait for government to catch up on this?
But as a small starting point on the next stage of this journey- could we question our use of the term ‘impairment’ and whether it could be holding us back in the creation of a more inclusive society?






