
Following the Access Association’ response to the PAS1899:2022 public consultation in May this year, the Association was invited to a meeting with the author to discuss the responses to the published draft and ‘some differences in research outputs for heights of charge point components’. Attending the 07 July meeting with Peter Weldon (PAS Author) on behalf of the Association were members: Jane Simpson, Caroline Lewis, James Taylor and Steve Hudson. Also in attendance were Kier Haines (Designability) and Heidi Lough (Office for Zero Emission Vehicles). A number of new draft diagrams developed by Designability for the PAS were provided prior to the meeting and used as the basis for discussion. The draft diagrams discussed included:
- Socket and Holster Height
- Touch and Visual Interface location and tilt
- Space around chargepoint and position of protection
- Parking provision for different layouts and orientation
- Wheel stops to avoid vehicle over-run adjacent pedestrian route /chargepoint
During discussions references were made to the outcomes from the SOSCI Durham user trials and comparisons to the Designability user trials in regard to component height location, reach requirements and user experience with display screen and printed information. Reference was also made to BS8300 published data and guidance on:
- Space requirements for access past and adjacent to parked vehicles, and car park ticket machines requiring user interaction with some similarities to chargepoint use
- Comfortable and extended reach requirements
- Bollard location, height and visual definition for persons with sight loss in vicinity of chargepoint and pedestrian route
Designability proposed the socket and holster aperture (horizontal centreline) height range between 750mm and 900mm, based on the experience from user trials, stating the minimum 750mm height was in recognition of the difficulty for some wheelchair users with limited reach capability who need to rest on their wheelchair armrests when accessing the charging socket. 900mm was a proposed compromise height for persons seated and standing based on the Durham user trials, where 850mm was preferred by seated users and 940mm by standing users and where a single socket is provided.
The draft diagram for visual and touch interface on chargepoints indicated a maximum height of 1300mm for visual interface, including payment systems. The diagram also indicated touch interface height, including payment systems, between 800mm and 1000mm, with the touch interface shown inclined with its lower edge tilted out from the charging device face at an angle in the range 10 to 20 degrees from the vertical. It was confirmed the guidance was intended to address the issues for charging device suppliers currently using touchscreens, but did not prescribe a requirement for touchscreens.
Issues discussed included:
- Any interface provision needs to serve the needs of standing and seated users
- Avoidance or reduction of glare and reflection on any visual surfaces and potential need for shading
- Avoidance of conflict between interface location and socket location for users accessibility
- Preference for minimal interaction for ease of use
- The importance of any instructions or other written information should be in plain English and the use of appropriate language should respect equality of all users.
- The need for the removal of the use of ‘enhanced accessibility’ was also recognised from the Associations response to the public consultation.
- The need to improve the list of terms and definitions was also advised, as well as the need to use terms matching with BS8300.
- Updates to terms and definitions were advised to include such as ‘footway’, ‘carriageway’ and ‘level access’, and guidance on vehicle bay surface should follow that in BS8300.
Space requirements at and around chargepoint and vehicle bay were discussed and improvements advised based on outcomes of the recent user trials and guidance in BS8300 including:
- A minimum of 1200mm straight line access past and chargepoint or other obstruction.
- 1600mm minimum (1800mm preferred) access depth to allow wheelchair turning in front of charging device.
- Marked access zones 1600mm preferred (1500mm minimum) width each side of vehicle bay to allow wheelchair user manoeuvring and turning for cable use and connection to vehicles with side power inlet socket; for vehicle bays at an angle to the kerb or pedestrian route.
- 1200mm wide marked safety zone for boot access and use of rear hoists outside of the traffic zone.
- Dimensions of any adjacent pedestrian route (a preferred provision) avoiding traffic zone should reflect existing guidance in BS8300, with drop kerb and accompanying tactile surface or level access from vehicle location.
- Description and dimensions of bollards were advised to reflect guidance in BS8300.
- Bollards location forward of the chargepoint were advised, including a minimum spacing of 1400mm apart between centres, to avoid obstruction to approach for users with impaired mobility; although different arrangements may be required relative to rapid charge devices.
It was generally agreed during the meeting that component heights should be stated relative to the location of the charging device user and not the location of the device, although for ease of access it will be preferable to locate the chargepoint at the same level as the vehicle bay with appropriate space around the vehicle and chargepoint for user access and interaction with the device: this advised protocol is expected to be adopted in the PAS.
The use of wheel stops within the vehicle bay to prevent vehicle overrun onto pedestrian access or chargepoint location were discussed. Concern was expressed due to potential trip hazard when unoccupied vehicle bay may be used as a thoroughfare, especially by anyone who is visually impaired or at night.
Concern was also expressed regarding limited potential for accessible charging provision on-street with bays parallel to kerb, or angled to kerb, where most existing carriageway widths and current Highways Regulations do not support provision of adequate space to accommodate access at vehicle bay level all-around a vehicle and clear of the vehicle route for persons with impaired mobility.
Follow-up exchanges with Peter by email expressed concerns over several issues including:
- Force required when inserting and extracting cable connector at socket.
- Potential need to accommodate chargepoint use by persons only able to interact using one hand and for persons unable to grasp cable in their hand.
- Advised inclusion of generic diagrams to clearly demonstrate the required user accessibility, including to any adjacent pedestrian route, and to reflect the need to ensure cable connection between vehicle and chargepoint can be achieved without cable stretched or hanging across access aisles / route and to minimise potential trip hazard with cable at foot level.
In response to the Association’s reply to the public consultation, the 07 July meeting, our follow-up soon thereafter, and involvement of those members who have also had involvement with the PAS Steering Group, there has been positive feedback on proposed changes to various passages in the PAS; including:
- the proposed reduction of the force to insert/extract cable at charging sockets to 30N;
- a socket height range of 800mm to 950mm with an explanatory notes (i.e. that seated users prefer the lower end of the height range, and that two sockets could be beneficial to suit all user needs);
- adoption of much of the advice on space standards and BS8300 referenced data;
- improvements to language use and terminology with removal of ‘enhanced accessibility’.
These issues and others, including any that are currently outside of the PAS remit, are expected to be carried forward for continuing review by a Technical Working Group and to consider any new data forthcoming from on-going work; such as for cable weight/insertion force and other accessibility related data. The expected publication date of the PAS is 11 October 2022, along with a BSI-led launch event webinar.






