
Picture by Eleanor Lisney: Sarah Rennie (centre), Georgie Hulme (right) and Adam Gabsi, a board member of Harrow Association of Disabled People and Inclusion London.
The government made a secret political decision that it would be too expensive and impractical to ensure that disabled people can safely evacuate from high-rise blocks of flats in emergencies, the high court has concluded.
A minister decided not to make the decision public because it would be “politically difficult to justify” and he feared “political fallout”, the court has found.
But despite these findings, the high court has dismissed an application by disabled campaigners for a judicial review and has found that the government’s decision was not unlawful.
The case was taken by Sarah Rennie, Georgie Hulme, and CLADDAG, the organisation they founded to campaign for disabled leaseholders and tenants in residential buildings impacted by the building safety crisis.
They brought the case after the government rejected the Grenfell Tower Inquiry’s recommendation that owners and managers of high-rise residential buildings should prepare a personal emergency evacuation plan (PEEP) for all residents who might find it difficult to “self-evacuate”.
The rejection of the PEEPs recommendation came even though those who responded to a consultation on the proposal overwhelmingly supported their introduction.
The Home Office consulted instead on its own “alternative package” of measures, which it calls Emergency Evacuation Information Sharing Plus, which does not go as far as PEEPs and will only apply to the minority of buildings that have been assessed as being “at higher risk”.





